Independent reviews of food dehydrators, from $65 stackers to stainless shelf modelsHow we make money

Home / Comparisons

Comparison

Stainless vs Plastic Dehydrator Trays

Cleaning, weight and price compared.

Stainless trays clean more easily and resist stains and odors, while plastic trays are lighter and come on cheaper dehydrators; neither changes how evenly food dries.

By The Dehydrator Report Editors · Updated November 11, 2026 · 4 min read

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never decides what we recommend. How we make money.

Tray material doesn't change how food dries; airflow and temperature do. It changes cleanup, durability and price.

Side by side

Stainless steelPlastic
CleaningMost go in the dishwasher; don't stainCan stain and hold odors
WeightHeavierLighter
PriceMostly on $160+ modelsOn most budget models
ExamplesCosori, Magic Mill, Tribest, Excalibur 10-TrayExcalibur 9-Tray, Nesco, Presto, Hamilton Beach

Cleaning

Stainless trays on the Magic Mill are dishwasher safe, and Cosori's trays clean up easily. Plastic trays can stain from fruit and hold marinade smells.

Sticking

Sticky foods cling to any tray. Use mesh screens for small pieces and leather sheets for purées; most shelf models include them.

Which to choose

If you'll dry often, stainless is worth it. See the best stainless dehydrators.

Sources

Keep reading